[5 Methods] Best Way to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza

When it comes to pizza, Papa John’s has earned its place among the top choices for pizza lovers. 

With their fresh ingredients and signature flavors, it’s no wonder people want to savor every last bite. But what do you do when you have some leftover Papa John’s pizza? The answer lies in reheating it to perfection.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the best ways to reheat Papa John’s pizza, ensuring that it retains its original taste and texture.

Best Way to Reheat Papa John's Pizza

About Papa John’s Pizza

Papa John’s Pizza is a well-known American pizza restaurant chain. The company is recognized for its commitment to using high-quality ingredients, including fresh dough, vine-ripened tomatoes for sauce, and quality meats and vegetables for toppings.

Papa John’s offers a variety of pizza options, including traditional favorites like pepperoni and cheese, as well as specialty pizzas with unique toppings and flavor combinations. 

They also serve other items such as breadsticks, chicken wings, and various side dishes. Over the years, Papa John’s has grown into one of the largest pizza delivery and takeout chains globally, with numerous locations in the United States and other countries. 

Importance of Reheating Papa John’s Pizza

Let’s go deeper into the significance of reheating Papa John’s Pizza. While reheating leftover pizza might seem like a simple kitchen task, it holds a surprising level of importance for several reasons:

Using the Leftovers

When you order a pizza from Papa John’s, it often comes in a standard size that may be more than you can consume in one sitting. Reheating allows you to enjoy the remaining slices at a later time, reducing food waste.

Preserving Taste and Texture

Pizza is at its best when it’s fresh out of the oven. Reheating can help restore some of the original taste and texture, making it more enjoyable than eating it cold.

Avoiding Foodborne Illness

Leaving pizza at room temperature for an extended period can promote bacterial growth and increase the risk of foodborne illness. Reheating leftover pizza before consuming it helps kill any potential bacteria, making it safer to eat.

Economical Aspect

Reheating pizza can be a cost-effective way to enjoy another meal without ordering additional food. It’s a convenient option, especially when you don’t want to cook from scratch.

For the Convenience 

Sometimes, reheating pizza is simply a matter of convenience. If you have leftover pizza in the fridge and you’re looking for a quick and easy meal, reheating is a straightforward solution.

Methods of Reheating Papa John’s Pizza

Ready to enjoy your Papa John’s Pizza again? We’ve got you covered with some simple and effective methods to reheat it just right.  Here are some easy ways to reheat it!

The Oven Method

Looking for the classic and time-tested way to reheat your leftover Papa John’s Pizza? Look no further than the Oven Method. To use this method follow the steps,

1. Gather Your Supplies

To reheat Papa John’s pizza in the oven, you’ll need:

2. Preheat Your Oven

Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). This ensures an even reheating process and maintains the crust’s crispy texture.

3. Prepare the Pizza

Place your pizza slices on the baking sheet or directly onto the oven-safe rack. Elevating the pizza on a rack can help prevent the crust from becoming soggy.

4. Reheating Time

Reheat for about 8-10 minutes or until the cheese is bubbling, and the crust regains its crispiness. Keep an eye on it to prevent overcooking.

5. Serve and Enjoy

Remove the pizza from the oven, let it cool for a minute, and then indulge in your perfectly reheated Papa John’s pizza.

The Skillet Method

When it comes to reheating Papa John’s Pizza, the skillet is your culinary ally. Its sizzle and finesse bring new life to leftover slices, ensuring that each bite is a crispy, cheesy delight. 

1. Get Your Equipment Ready

For this stovetop method, you’ll need:

  • Papa John’s pizza slices
  • A non-stick skillet with a lid

2. Heat the Skillet

Place your skillet on medium-low heat and let it warm up while you prepare the pizza.

3. Prep the Pizza

Place the pizza slice(s) in the skillet, cover it with the lid, and let it cook for 2-4 minutes.

4. Check for Crispiness

Lift the lid and check the crust. When it’s crispy and the cheese is melting, it’s ready.

5. Plate and Serve

Remove the pizza from the skillet, let it cool for a minute, and savor the amazing taste of your reheated Papa John’s creation.

The Microwave Method

Craving a quick fix for your leftover Papa John’s Pizza? Look no further than the microwave! Discover the speedy secret to reheating perfection in minutes.

1. Gather Your Tools

To reheat Papa John’s pizza in the microwave, you’ll need:

  • Papa John’s pizza slices
  • A microwave-safe plate
  • A microwave-safe cup of water

2. Add Moisture

Place the cup of water in the microwave next to the pizza. This helps maintain some moisture in the reheating environment and prevents the crust from turning into cardboard.

3. Microwave in Intervals

Heat the pizza in 30-second intervals at medium power. Check after each interval and stop when it reaches your desired temperature.

4. Rest and Enjoy

Allow the pizza to rest for a minute to avoid burning your mouth with molten cheese, and then savor the flavors of your reheated Papa John’s masterpiece.

The Toaster Oven Method

The toaster oven method offers the perfect solution for crispy, delicious slices in no time. Lets check out the actual process pf reheating.

1. Equipment Check

For this method, gather:

  • Papa John’s pizza slices
  • A toaster oven

2. Preheat the Toaster Oven

Preheat your toaster oven to 375°F (190°C), just like you would with a regular oven.

3. Place the Pizza

Lay your pizza slices directly on the toaster oven rack or on a baking sheet if you prefer.

4. Toast to Perfection

Reheat for about 5-7 minutes or until the cheese is bubbly, and the crust regains its crispiness.

5. Serve and Savor

Once reheated, take your pizza out of the toaster oven, let it cool briefly, and dive into a slice of Papa John’s heaven.

The Air Fryer Method

The Air Fryer Method of Reheating Papa John’s Pizza takes pizza enjoyment to a whole new level. With its sizzling hot air and precision cooking, the air fryer promises to transform your leftover pizza into a crispy, cheesy masterpiece.

1. Assemble Your Gear

To reheat Papa John’s pizza in an air fryer, you’ll need:

  • Papa John’s pizza slices
  • An air fryer

2. Preheat the Air Fryer

Preheat your air fryer to 350°F (175°C) for a few minutes.

3. Reheat the Pizza

Place the pizza slices in the air fryer basket in a single layer. Heat for 3-5 minutes until the cheese melts and the crust crisps up.

4. Savor the Flavors

Remove your reheated Papa John’s pizza from the air fryer, give it a moment to cool down, and then treat your taste buds to a slice of pizza perfection.

Final Tips for Pizza Perfection

Regardless of the method you choose to reheat your Papa John’s pizza, here are some additional tips to ensure a satisfying experience:

1. Don’t Overcrowd

Whether using an oven, skillet, microwave, toaster oven, or air fryer, avoid overcrowding the heating surface. This allows for even reheating and prevents a soggy outcome.

2. Preserve the Crust:

If crispy crust is your priority, consider using a pizza stone or a cast iron skillet for reheating. These methods excel at maintaining crust crispiness.

3. Use a Damp Paper Towel:

When reheating in the microwave, placing a damp paper towel over the pizza slices can help retain moisture and prevent the crust from getting too hard.

4. Experiment and Enjoy:

Don’t be afraid to experiment with different methods to find your favorite way to reheat Papa John’s pizza. It’s all about personal preference.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the Best Method to Maintain the Original Taste and Texture?

The oven method usually preserves the crust’s crispiness and overall texture the best.

Can I Reheat a Whole Pizza in the Oven?

Yes, you can reheat a whole Papa John’s pizza in the oven by following the same method, just adjust the time accordingly.

Does Reheating Pizza in the Oven Take a Long Time?

It typically takes around 8-10 minutes in the oven to reheat pizza.

Can I Reheat Pizza in the Toaster Oven With the Box It Came In?

No, it’s not recommended to reheat pizza in its original box. Use a toaster oven-safe tray or rack.

Can I Reheat Deep-Dish Papa John’s Pizza Using These Methods?

Yes, you can reheat deep-dish Papa John’s pizza using the same methods. Adjust the time as needed.

Can I Reheat Pizza if It Has Been in the Refrigerator for Several Days?

Yes, you can reheat refrigerated pizza. It’s safe as long as it’s stored properly.

What Should I Do if the Pizza’s Crust Becomes Too Crispy During Reheating?

Reduce the reheating time or temperature slightly to prevent over-crisping.

Can I Add Extra Toppings Before Reheating the Pizza?

Yes, you can add extra toppings before reheating to customize your pizza.

What’s the Best Way to Revive the Flavor of Reheated Pizza?

Consider adding a sprinkle of fresh herbs or a drizzle of olive oil after reheating for an extra burst of flavor.


When it comes to enjoying leftover Papa John’s pizza, you have several methods at your disposal. Whether you opt for the oven’s even heating, the stovetop’s quick and crispy approach, the microwave’s convenience, the toaster oven’s precision, or the air fryer’s speed, you can relish the flavors of your favorite pizza chain once again. Choose the method that suits your taste, and never let a Papa John’s slice go to waste. Happy reheating!

Leave a Comment